Mediation with a Narcissist: Can It Work?

Author: SiLaw Group Family Lawyers
Published: Nov 5, 2024
Read time: 4 min read

---

Yes — mediation with a narcissist can work, but usually only with careful preparation and a mediator who screens for family violence and manages the power imbalance. In some high-conflict cases, court is the safer route. Here is how to tell the difference.

Understanding Narcissistic Personality Disorder (NPD)

Narcissistic Personality Disorder (NPD) is a mental health condition marked by a lack of empathy, an inflated sense of self-worth, and a constant need for admiration. Narcissists often view themselves as superior, have an intense sensitivity to criticism, and may struggle with seeing others' perspectives. In divorce mediation, these traits make it difficult for a narcissist to engage in self-reflection or compromise—two essential components of successful mediation.

Recognizing the Traits of Narcissism

If you're heading into mediation and suspect your ex-partner may have narcissistic tendencies, here are some signs to watch for:

1. Inflated self-importance and need for admiration
2. Excessive sensitivity to criticism
3. Self-centeredness at the expense of others
4. Reluctance to compromise

These characteristics can make reaching a fair agreement challenging, as a narcissist is often more focused on "winning" than finding a mutually beneficial solution.

The Unique Challenges of Mediating with a Narcissist

Mediation can provide a platform to negotiate important issues such as parental responsibilities, spousal support, and property division. However, a narcissist may approach mediation as a battleground, rather than a cooperative process. Here's how these tendencies might complicate mediation:

• Difficulty Compromising: Narcissists see mediation as a competition and may be unwilling to make concessions.
• Playing the Victim: A narcissist may manipulate the narrative to appear as the wronged party, often distorting reality to justify their stance.
• Gaslighting: Narcissists may try to confuse or manipulate others' perceptions, including the mediator's, by offering alternate versions of events.

Fortunately, professional mediators are trained to recognize these behaviors and work around them. By identifying these tactics, they help keep sessions focused and equitable.

In British Columbia, this screening is not optional: under section 8 of the Family Law Act, a family dispute resolution professional consulted by a party must assess, in accordance with the regulations, whether family violence may be present and, if it appears to be present, the extent to which it may adversely affect the safety of that party or a family member and the party's ability to negotiate a fair agreement — directly relevant where narcissistic abuse is a concern. In BC Supreme Court family proceedings, a party can also require the other side to participate in mediation by serving a Notice to Mediate under the Notice to Mediate (Family) Regulation. It can generally be served no earlier than 90 days after the first response to family claim is filed and no later than 90 days before trial, and a party may be exempted — by agreement, where the mediator assesses that mediation is not appropriate, where a protection order or peace bond is in place, or by court order. The mediator must hold a pre-mediation meeting separately with each participant and must screen for power imbalance, domestic violence and abuse before any joint session.

Preparing for Mediation with a Narcissist

Preparation is key. Before you begin, consider these strategies:

1. Limit Interaction Outside of Mediation: Narcissists thrive on conflict, so avoid engaging in discussions outside of the mediation room. This limits opportunities for manipulation.

2. Set Personal Boundaries: Decide what you are and aren't willing to compromise on. Clear boundaries help protect your interests and keep discussions productive.

3. Stay Calm and Focused: Narcissists may provoke you to get an emotional response. Staying composed helps you maintain control and prevent the conversation from escalating.

4. Document Everything: Keep records of any manipulative behavior or actions that might affect the mediation. These can be useful if the process moves to court.

   For further preparation, see our top ten books to read after a separation — the list includes Bill Eddy's guides to communicating with high-conflict personalities.

5. Work Closely with Your Mediator: Let the mediator take charge. Mediators understand how to manage narcissistic behaviors and can redirect the session back to productive dialogue when needed.

The Mediator's Role in High-Conflict Divorce

Experienced mediators play a crucial role in managing power imbalances and fostering a constructive negotiation environment. A skilled mediator will:

1. Guide the session to keep the focus on key issues.
2. Reframe issues to make them more palatable for both parties.
3. Enforce boundaries and maintain an environment of respect and neutrality.
4. When dealing with a narcissist, a mediator may also use techniques to ensure that the narcissist feels they have a voice, which can prevent confrontations from escalating.

When to Know Mediation May Not Be Effective

While mediation can work in some cases, it may not always be the answer. If your ex-partner has severe NPD, they may be too rigid or manipulative to allow for a successful mediation process. When sessions stagnate with little to no progress, consider shifting to court proceedings, which offer structured timelines and enforceable decisions.

	Mediation	Court
Who decides	You and your ex-partner shape the agreement	A judge makes the decisions
Structure	Flexible sessions guided by the mediator	Fixed timelines and rules of procedure
Conflict management	Depends on the mediator managing behaviour and power imbalance	Formal process limits direct confrontation
When it fits	Both parties can negotiate with support and screening	Severe NPD, stalled sessions, or safety concerns

Protecting Your Children in Parenting Arrangements

Narcissistic behaviour can have significant impacts on children. During mediation involving parenting arrangements and parental responsibilities, present any evidence of harmful behaviours and prioritise arrangements that protect your children's emotional and mental well-being. In some cases, supervised parenting time or structured communication strategies may be necessary to shield your children from the effects of narcissistic tendencies.

Post-Mediation Strategies for Maintaining Boundaries

Once mediation concludes, it is essential to have post-mediation strategies in place. Document interactions and keep communication structured and limited. If your ex-partner disregards the agreement, seek legal guidance to ensure compliance.

Choosing the Right Mediator

While mediation with a narcissist is undoubtedly challenging, it is possible with the right support and preparation.

Our mediator, Sandy Sihota, is accredited as a Family Law Mediator and understands how narcissistic behaviours play out in mediation. She can guide the process while maintaining a balance that protects your interests and those of your children. The journey won't be easy, but with patience and persistence, mediation can provide a pathway to resolution and a brighter, more peaceful future. Learn more about our family mediation services, or contact one of our Surrey, BC family law mediators today at Silaw Group Family Lawyers & Mediation by calling 1.778.381.9977 or by booking a free consultation online.

---

Tags:

• Mediation
• Narcissist
• Family Law Act
• BC Family Law Mediator

Category:

• Mediation